| 406 | 1 | 39 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
锡料是青铜器生产的关键物质资源,其来源及流通途径问题是中国乃至世界范围内青铜时代研究的重要议题之一。通过对锡同位素这一新兴锡料溯源方法的梳理归纳,结合地中海青铜时代青铜器锡料来源研究的应用实践,以及对中国盘龙城遗址和琉璃河遗址锡料来源的初探,为中国青铜器锡料产地与来源等考古问题的解决提供新思路。
Abstract:Tin is an important material resource for bronze production, and the issue of its origin and circulation is one of the important issues in Bronze Age research in China and worldwide.By combing and summarizing the new method of tin isotope tracing, combined with the application practice of the research on tin source of Mediterranean Bronze Age bronzes, and the preliminary study on tin source of Panlongcheng Site and Liulihe Site in China based on the above basis, the new ideas for solving the archaeological problems of tin origin and source of Chinese bronzes were provided.
[1] LEHMANNN B.Formation of tin ore deposits:a reassessment[J].Lithos,2020:105756.DOI:10.1016/j.lithos.2020.105756.
[2] 石璋如.殷代的铸铜工艺[J].中央研究院历史语言研究所集刊,1955,26:95-129.SHI Z R.Copper casting in the Yin Dynasty[J].Collected Works of the Institute of Historical and Linguistic Studies,Academia Sinica,1955,26:95-129.
[3] 天野元之助.殷代产业に关する若干の问题[J].东方学报,1953(2):231-237.MOTONOSUKEA.Some problems related to Shang Dynasty industry[J].Oriental Journal,1953(2):231-237.
[4] 闻广.中原古代青铜与锡矿[J].地质评论,1980,26(4):331-240.WEN G.Ancient bronze and tin mining in the Central Plains[J].Geological Review,1980,26(4):331-240.
[5] 童恩正,魏启鹏,范勇.“中原找锡论”质疑[J].四川大学学报(哲学社会科学版),1984(4):80-99.TONG E Z,WEI Q P,FAN Y.Questioning the theory of "finding tin in the Central Plains"[J].Journal of Sichuan University(Philosophy and Social Science Edition),1984(4):80-99.
[6] 张光直.考古学专题六讲[M].北京:文物出版社,1986:124-132.ZHANG G Z.Six lectures on topics in archaeology[M].Beijing:Cultural Relics Press,1986:124-132.
[7] 夏湘蓉,仲均,王根元.中国古代矿业开发史[M].北京:地质出版社,1980:207-209.XIA X R,ZHONG J,WANG G Y.History of mining development in ancient China[M].Beijing:Geology Press,1980:207-209.
[8] 翦伯赞.中国史纲要:第一卷[M].上海:三联书店,1950:207.JIAN B Z.Outline of Chinese history:Volume 1[M].Shanghai:SDX Joint Publishing Company,1950:207.
[9] 郭沫若.青铜时代[M].北京:人民出版社,1954:297-308.GUO M R.Bronze age[M].Beijing:People′s Publishing House,1954:297-308.
[10] 陆秋燕,李延祥.广西各类型铜鼓的分布与铜锡铅矿点之间的关系:兼论广西古代铜鼓矿料来源和铸造地问题[J].广西民族研究,2017(1):143-148.LU Q Y,LI Y X.The relationship between distribution of various types of bronze drums and ores source in Guangxi:also on the ores source and cast site of ancient bronze drums in Guangxi[J].Guangxi Ethnic Studies,2017(1):143-148.
[11] 刘锦新.泛论我国锡矿的主要成因:工业类型的特征及其成矿分区[J].锡矿地质参考之(三),1980:199-202.LIU J X.A general discussion on the main causes of tin ores in China:characteristics of industrial types and their mineralization zoning[J].Tin Mining Geological References(Ⅲ),1980:199-202.
[12] 廖苏平.试论中国青铜时代锡矿的来源[J].南方文物,2002(2):30-40.LIAO S P.An experimental study of the sources of tin ore in Bronze Age China[J].Cultural Relics in Southern China,2002(2):30-40.
[13] 陈光祖.商代锡料来源初探[J].考古,2012(6):54-68.CHEN G Z.A preliminary study on the sources of tin in the Shang Dynasty[J].Archaeology,2012(6):54-68.
[14] 南普恒,潜伟,李延祥,等.羊舌晋侯墓地铜器矿料来源的微量元素分析[J].中原文物,2017(2):100-106.NAN P H,QIAN W,LI Y X,et al.On the copper provenance of bronze unearthed from the Yangshe Cemetery:a trace-element study[J].Cultural Relics of Central China,2017(2):100-106.
[15] 金正耀.晚商中原青铜的矿料来源研究[D].合肥:中国科学技术大学,1984.JIN Z Y.A study on the ore sources of Late Shang Central Plains bronzes[D].Hefei:University of Science and Technology of China,1984.
[16] 易德生.科技考古视野下的商王朝锡料来源与“金道锡行”[J].中国社会科学,2013(5):163-185.YI D S.The source of tin and the “Copper-tin Road” of the Shang Dynasty in the perspective of Archaeometry[J].Social Sciences in China,2013(5):163-185.
[17] 田建花,马江波.先秦青铜生产的锡料来源探讨[J].有色金属(冶炼部分),2017(12):67-72.TIAN J H,MA J B.Discussion on sources of tin material for Bronze production in Pre-Qin Dynasty[J].Nonferrous Metals(Extractive Metallurgy),2017(12):67-72.
[18] MOLOFSKY L J,KIKKICK D,DUCEA M N,et al.A novel approach to lead isotope provenance studies of tin and bronze:applications to South African,Botswanan and Romanian artifacts[J].Journal of Archaeological Science,2014,50:440-450.
[19] BEGEMANN F,KALLAS K,SCHMITT-STRECKER S,et al.Tracing ancient tin via isotope analyses[J].Diseases of the Nervous System,1999.DOI:10.1007/BF01562517.
[20] GALILI E,GALE N,ROSEN B.A late Bronze Age shipwreck with a metal cargo from Hishuley Carmel,Israel[J].International Journal of Nautical Archaeology,2013,42(1):2-23.
[21] BERGER D,BRüGMANN G,PERNICKA E.On smelting cassiterite in geological and archaeological samples:preparation and implications for provenance studies on metal artefacts with tin isotopes[J].Springer Berlin Heidelberg,2019(1).DOI:10.1007/s12520-017-0544-z.
[22] ROSMAN K J R,LOSS R D,LAETER J R D.The isotopic composition of tin[J].International Journal of Mass Spectrometry & Ion Processes,1984,56(3):281-291.
[23] ROSMAN K J R,MCNAUGHTON N J.High-precision measurement of isotopic fractionation in tin[J].International Journal of Mass Spectrometry and Ion Processes,1987,75(1):91-98.
[24] GALE N H.The isotopic composition of tin in some ancient metals and the recycling problem in metal provenancing[J].Archaeometry,2010,39(1):71-82.
[25] CLAYTON R,ANDERSSON P,GALE N H,et al.Precise determination of the isotopic composition of Sn using MC-ICP-MS[J].Journal of Analytical Atomic Spectrometry,2002,17(10):1248-1256.
[26] MOYNIER F,FUJII T,TELOUK P.Mass-independent isotopic fractionation of tin in chemical exchange reaction using a crown ether[J].Analytica Chimica Acta,2009,632(2):234-239.
[27] WANG X,FITOUSSI C,BOURDON B,et al.A new method of Sn purification and isotopic determination with a double-spike technique for geological and cosmochemical samples[J].Journal of Analytical Atomic Spectrometry,2017,32(5):1009-1019.
[28] ALBAREDE F,TELOUK P,BLICHERT-TOFT J,et al.Precise and accurate isotopic measurements using multiple-collector ICPMS[J].Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta,2004,68(12):2728-2744.
[29] 王倩,侯清华,张婷,等.铜同位素测定方法研究进展[J].矿物岩石地球化学通报,2016,35(3):497-506.WANG Q,HOU Q H,ZHANG T,et al.Progresses of copper isotope analytical methods[J].Bulletin of Mineralogy,Petrology and Geochemistry,2016,35(3):497-506.
[30] CREECH J B,MOYNIER F,BADULLOVICH N.Tin stable isotope analysis of geological materials by double-spike MC-ICPMS[J].Chemical Geology,2017,457:61-67.
[31] POWELL W,YAO J M,MATHUR R,et al.Sn-isotope fractionation as a record of hydrothermal redox reactions[J].American Mineralogist,2018,103:1591-1598.
[32] WANG D,MATHUR R,POWELL W,et al.Experimental evidence for fractionation of tin chlorides by redox and vapor mechanisms[J].Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta,2019,250:209-218.
[33] BRUEGMANN G,LOCKHOFF N,ROBERTS B W,et al.The Salcombe metal cargoes:new light on the provenance and circulation of tin and copper in Later Bronze Age Europe provided by trace elements and isotopes[J].Journal of Archaeological Science,2022,138:105543.DOI:10.1016/j.jas.2022.105543.
[34] YAMAZAKI E,NAKAI S I,YOKOYAMA T,et al.Tin isotope analysis of cassiterites from Southeastern and Eastern Asia[J].Geochemical Journal,2013,47(1):21-35.
[35] BALLIANA E,ARAMEND M,RESANO M.Copper and tin isotopic analysis of ancient bronzes for archaeological investigation:development and validation of a suitable analytical methodology[J].Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry,2013,405(9):2973-2986.
[36] MASON A H,POWELL W G,BANKOFF H A,et al.Tin isotope characterization of bronze artifacts of the central Balkans[J].Journal of Archaeological Science,2016,69:110-117.
[37] BERGER D,FIGUEIREDO E,BRUGMANN G,et al.Tin isotope fractionation during experimental cassiterite smelting and its implication for tracing the tin sources of prehistoric metal artefacts[J].Journal of Archaeological Science,2018,92:73-86.
[38] BERGER D,SOLES J S,GIUMLIA-MAIR A R,et al.Isotope systematics and chemical composition of tin ingots from Mochlos(Crete)and other Late Bronze Age sites in the eastern Mediterranean Sea:an ultimate key to tin provenance?[J].PLoS ONE,2019,14(6):e0218326.DOI:10.1371/journal.pone.0218326.
[39] BERGER D,BRUEGMANN G,FRIEDRICH R,et al.Shiny bronze in glassy matter:an inconspicuous piece of slag from the Bronze Age mining site of Musiston(Tajikistan)and its significance for the development of tin metallurgy in Central Asia[J].Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences,2022.DOI:10.1007/s12520-022-01606-2.
[40] BERGER D,BRüGMANN G,BUNNEFELD J,et al.Identifying mixtures of metals by multi-isotope analysis:disentangling the relationships of the Early Bronze Age swords of the Apa-Hajdusámson type and associated objects[J].Archaeometry,2021.DOI:10.1111/arcm.12714.
[41] LI C Y,ZHANG R Q,DING X,et al.Dating cassiterite using laser ablation ICP-MS[J].Ore Geology Reviews,2016,72:313-322.
[42] GUO J,ZHANG R Q,LI C Y,et al.Genesis of the Gaosong Sn-Cu deposit,Gejiu district,SW China:constraints from in situ LA-ICP-MS cassiterite U-Pb dating and trace element fingerprinting[J].Ore Geology Reviews,2018,92:627-642.
[43] YUAN S D,PENG J T,HU R Z,et al.A precise U-Pb age on cassiterite from the Xianghualing tin-polymetallic deposit(Hunan,South China)[J].Mineralium Deposita,2008,43(4):375-382.
[44] ZHANG R Q,LEHMANN B,SELTMANN R,et al.Cassiterite U-Pb geochronology constrains magmatic-hydrothermal evolution in complex evolved granite systems:the classic Erzgebirge tin province(Saxony and Bohemia)[J].Geology,2017,45(12):1095-1098.
[45] 涂家润,崔玉荣,周红英,等.锡石U-Pb定年方法评述[J].地质调查与研究,2019(12):241-249.TU J R,CUI Y R,ZHOU H Y,et al.Review of U-Pb dating methods for cassiterite[J].Geological Survey and Research,2019(12):241-249.
[46] MOSCATI R J,NEYMARK L A.U-Pb geochronology of tin deposits associated with the Cornubian Batholith of southwest England:direct dating of cassiterite by in situ LA-ICPMS[J].Mineralium Deposita,2020,55(1):DOI:10.1130/g39634.1.
[47] GANERD M,CHEW D M,SMETHURST M A,et al.Geochronology of the tardree rhyolite complex,Northern Ireland:implications for zircon fission track studies,the North Atlantic Igneous province and the age of the Fish Canyon sanidine standard[J].Chemical Geology,2011,286(3/4):222-228.
[48] MARIGNAC C,CUNEY M.Ore deposits of the French Massif Central:insight into the metallogenesis of the Variscan collision belt[J].Mineralium Deposita,1999,34(5/6):472-504.
[49] LEROUGE C,GLOAGUEN E,WILLE G,et al.Distribution of In and other rare metals in cassiterite and associated minerals in Sn±W ore deposits of the western Variscan Belt[J].European Journal of Mineralogy,2017.DOI:10.1127/ejm/2017/0029-2673.
[50] ROMER R L,THOMAS R,STEIN H J,et al.Dating multiply overprinted Sn-mineralized granites:examples from the Erzgebirge,Germany[J].Mineralium Deposita,2007,42(4):337-359.
[51] RIZVANOVA N G,SKUBLOV S G,CHEREMAZOVA E V.Geology age of hydrothermal processes in the Central Iberian zone(Spain)according to U-Pb dating of cassiterite and apatite[J].2018.DOI:10.18454/PMI.2017.3.275.
[52] BONI M,STEIN H J,ZIMMERMAN A,et al.Re-Os age for molybdenite from SW Sardinia(Italy):a comparison with 40Ar/39Ar dating of Variscan granitoids[J].Millpress,2003:247-250.
[53] HURAI V,CHOVAN M,MONIKA H,et al.Slovak ore mountains:origin of hydrothermal mineralization and environmental impacts of mining[J].Acta Mineralogica-Petrographica,2010:2-36.
[54] PAVLOVA G G,BORISENKO A S.The age of Ag-Sb deposits of central Asia and their correlation with other types of ore systems and magmatism[J].Ore Geology Reviews,2009;35(2):164-185.
[55] SELTMANN R.Preliminary non-fuel mineral resource assessment of Afghanistan-2007[M/OL].Afghanistan Geological Survey,2001.DOI:10.2113/econgeo.107.7.1515-a
[56] MELCHER F,GRAUPNER T,HANS-EIKE G,et al.Tantalum-(niobium-tin)mineralisation in African pegmatites and rare metal granites:constraints from Ta-Nb oxide mineralogy,geochemistry and U-Pb geochronology[J].Ore Geology Reviews,2015,64:667-719.
[57] YENER K A,SAYRE E V,JOEL E C,et al.Stable lead isotope studies of central Taurus ore sources and related artifacts from eastern Mediterranean Chalcolithic and Bronze Age sites[J].Journal of Archaeological Science,1991,18(5):541-577.
[58] YAZGAN E.Cassiterite(tin)mineralization related with Erciyes Volcanic Activities and the mode of formation of the Hematite-Cassiterite-Yazganite-Tridymite Paragenesis and its implication for bronze alloys[J].2013.DOI:10.13140/RG.2.2.14894.51527.
[59] POWELL W,JOHNSON M,PULAK C,et al.From peaks to ports:insights into tin provenance,production,and distribution from adapted applications of lead isotopic analysis of the Uluburun tin ingots[J].Journal of Archaeological Science,2021,134:105455.DOI:10.1016/j.jas.2021.105455.
[60] RAPP G.Trace elements as a guide to the geographical source of tin ore smelting experiments[M]//FRANKLIN A D,OLIN J S,WERTIME T A.The search for ancient tin.U.S.Government Printing Office,Washington D C,1978:59-63.
[61] GRANT M R.The sourcing of Southern African tin artifacts[J].Journal of Archaeological Science,1999,26(8):1111-1117.
[62] ROTHE R D,Jr GRR.Trace element analysis of Egyptian eastern desert tin and its importance to Egyptian archaeology[M]//HUSSEIN A,MIELE M,RIAD S.Proceedings of the Egyptian-Italian seminar on the geosciences and archaeology in the Mediterranean countries.Special Publication 70.Cairo:The Geological Survey of Egypt,1995:229-244.
[63] MASON A,POWELL W,BANKOFF H A,et al.Provenance of tin in the Late Bronze Age balkans based on probabilistic and spatial analysis of Sn isotopes[J].Journal of Archaeological Science,2020,122:105181.DOI:10.1016/j.jas.2020.105181.
[64] MUHLY J D.New evidence of sources and trade in Bronze Age tin[M]//FRANKLIN A D,OLIN J S,WERTIME T A.The search for ancient tin.Washington D C:Smithsonian Institute Press,1978:43-48.
[65] MUHLY J D.Tin trade routes of the Bronze Age[J].American Scientist,1973,61:404-413.
[66] MUHLY J D.Sources of tin and the beginnings of bronze metallurgy[J].American Journal of Archaeology,1985,89(2):275-291.
[67] CIERNY J,WEISGERBER G.Bronze Age tin mines in central Asia[M]//GIUMLIA-MAIR A R,LO SCHIAVO F.The problem of early tin:acts of the ⅩⅣth UISPP Congress,University of Liège,Belgium,2-8 September 2001.BAR International Series 1199.Oxford:Archaeopress,2003:23-31.
[68] ST?LLNER T,SAMASCHEV Z,BERDENOV S,et al.Tin from Kazakhstan:steppe tin for the West[M]//YAL?Nü.Anatolian Metal V.Der Anschnitt,Beiheft 24.Bochum:Deutsches Bergbau-Museum;2011:231-252.
[69] GARNER J.Das zinn der bronzezeit in Mittelasien Ⅱ:die montanarch?ologischen forschungen an den Zinnlagerst?tten[C]//Arch?ologie in Iran und Turan 12.Ver?ffentlichungen aus dem Deutschen Bergbau Museum Bochum 194.Bochum:Deutsches Bergbau-Museum,2013.
[70] GARNER J.Bronze Age tin mines in central Asia[C]//HAUPTMANN A,MODARRESSI-TEHRANI D.Archaeometallurgy in Europe Ⅲ:proceedings of the 3rd International Conference,Deutsches Bergbau-Museum Bochum,June 29-July 1,2011.Der Anschnitt,Beiheft 26.Bochum:Deutsches Bergbau-Museum,2015:135-143.
[71] YENER K A,OZBAL H.Kestel:an early Bronze Age source of tin ore in the Taurus Mountains,Turkey[J].Science,1989:244,200-203.
[72] YENER K A,KULAKOLU F,YAZGAN E,et al.New tin mines and production sites near Kültepe in Turkey:a third-millennium BC highland production model[J].Antiquity,2015,89(345):596-612.
[73] NEZAFATI N,PERNICKA E,MOMENZADEH M.Introduction of the Deh Hosein ancient tin-copper mine,western Iran:evidence from geology,archaeology,geochemistry and lead isotope data[J].TUBA-AR,2009(12):223-236.
[74] CLEUZIOU S,BERTHOUD T.Early tin in The Near East:a reassessment in the light of new evidence from Western Afghanistan[J].Expedition,1982,25(1):14-19.
[75] PARZINGER H,BOROFKA N.Woher stammt das zinn der bronzezeit in Mittelasien[J].Arch?ologie in Deutschland,2001(3):12-17.
[76] PARZINGER H,BOROFKA N.Das zinn der bronzezeit in Mittelasien Ⅰ:die siedlungsarch?ologischen untersuchungen im umfeld der Zinnlagerst?tten.Arch?logie in Iran und Turan 5[C]//Philipp von Zabern,Mainz,2003.
[77] THORNTON C P,LIEZERS L K,LIEZERS C C,et al.Stech and pigott revisited:new evidence concerning the origins of tin bronze in the light of chemical and metallographic analyses of the metal artefacts from Tepe Yahya,Iran[C]//KARS H,BURKE E.Proceedings of the 33rd International Symposium on Archaeometry.22-26.April 2002,Amsterdam.Geoarchaeological and Bioarchaeological Studies 3.University of Amsterdam,Amsterdam,2022:395-398.
[78] YAMAZAKI E,NAKAI S,SAHOO Y,et al.Feasibility studies of Sn isotope composition for provenancing ancient bronzes[J].Journal of Archaeological Science,2014,52:458-467.
[79] 彭子成,孙卫东,黄允兰,等.赣鄂皖诸地古代矿料去向的初步研究[J].考古,1997(7):53-61.PENG Z C,SUN W D,HUANG Y L,et al.A preliminary study on the destination of ancient mineral materials in Jiangxi,Hubei and Anhui provinces[J].Archaeology,1997(7):53-61.
基本信息:
中图分类号:TS934;K876.41
引用信息:
[1]李倩.锡同位素在青铜器锡料来源研究中的应用探讨[J].有色金属(冶炼部分),2024(01):160-170.
2023-12-21
2023-12-21